A cookie that even your mother-in-law can’t complain about.

Shop all

Best Sellers

How Our Pricing Works

Every cookie from Riley’s Cookie Creations is thoughtfully priced to reflect the care, quality, and time that go into making it.

Quality ingredients

Our pricing begins with the cost of the ingredients used in each order. Recipe choices, flavors, colors, and design details can all affect the final cost.

Time and skilled labor

Custom cookies involve much more than baking. Each order can include planning, shopping, preparing dough, baking, decorating by hand, drying, packaging, and cleanup. More detailed or intricate cookies require additional time and are priced accordingly.

Packaging

Packaging helps keep your cookies fresh, protected, and ready to enjoy or give as a gift. The final price includes the materials needed to package and present each order with care.

Why prices may vary

Every order is different. Quantity, size, flavor, design complexity, colors, personalization, packaging, and turnaround time can all influence the quote. Before work begins, you’ll receive clear pricing based on the details of your request.

Thank you for supporting a small business and the craftsmanship behind every batch. We’re honored to create something sweet for your celebration!